Learning new categories: Adults tend to use rules while children sometimes rely on family resemblance
نویسندگان
چکیده
We conducted an experiment in which children and adults were asked to learn a set of categories for which a single-feature rule (the criterial attribute) or overall family resemblance would allow for perfect performance. Test stimuli were presented after the category was learned and were designed such that the information provided by the rule conflicted with the information provided by the family resemblance structure. We found that adults made significantly more rule-based responses to the test stimuli than did the children. These data suggest that although adults default to verbal rules under standard learning conditions, children may rely instead on an implicit, non-verbal system to learn the same categories.
منابع مشابه
Bottom-up attentional cueing in category learning in children
Young children tend to differ from adults in how they learn new categories. In comparison to adults (who rely on selective attention and tend to form explicit rules), children distribute attention widely, forming similarity-based category representations. But, when attention is explicitly directed toward the rule with top-down feedback, children exhibit rulebased classification–though memory pe...
متن کاملChildren and adults learn family-resemblance categories analytically.
3 experiments examined the modes of processing used by children and adults in learning family-resemblance categories. The materials were cartoon faces (Experiments 1 and 2) and bugs (Experiment 3) divided into categories that possessed no single defining attributes, but rather several characteristic attributes that were each partially predictive of category membership. The categories were struc...
متن کاملRules and Similarity in the Development of Category Learning in Children and Infants
Most theorists agree that adults can learn and use categories that are both ruleand similarity-based. There is less agreement about the mechanisms involved or on the distinction between rules and similarity. We begin by reviewing two recent theoretical positions, that of Pothos (2005) and of Ashby & colleagues (Ashby et al., 1998; Ashby and O’Brien, 2005). Identifying the notion of a rule to be...
متن کاملInstantiated features and the use of "rules.".
Classification "rules" in expert and everyday discourse are usually deficient by formal standards, lacking explicit decision procedures and precise terms. The authors argue that a central function of such weak rules is to focus on perceptual learning rather than to provide definitions. In 5 experiments, transfer following learning of family resemblance categories was influenced more by familiar...
متن کاملUsing Wittgenstein ’ s family resemblance principle to learn exemplars
The introduction of the notion of family resemblance represented a major shift in Wittgenstein’s thoughts on the meaning of words, moving away from a belief that words were well defined, to a view that words denoted less well defined categories of meaning. This paper presents the use of the notion of family resemblance in the area of machine learning as an example of the benefits that can accru...
متن کامل